BMW’s X3 and X5 SUVs both offer a luxurious ride, but they appeal to different types of drivers. The X3 is a bit smaller and more affordable, while the X5 offers more space, features, and power — at a higher price point.
So, which one is right for you? That’s what we’re here to help you figure out. We’ll break down the key differences between the BMW X3 vs X5, including their dimensions, performance specs, interior features, technology, and overall practicality.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your individual needs and lifestyle. Are you looking for a sporty and agile SUV for city driving? Or do you need a spacious and capable vehicle for family trips and weekend adventures? Read on, and we’ll help you decide.
Dimensions and Exterior Design: Size Matters
The most obvious difference between the BMW X5 and the X3 is their size. The X5 is noticeably larger than the X3. The X5 measures 194.2 inches long and 78.9 inches wide, while the X3 comes in at 187.2 inches long and 75.6 inches wide.
This size difference has implications for maneuverability and parking, especially if you live in a city. The smaller X3 is easier to navigate through crowded streets and fit into tight parking spots. If you live in a more rural area, this may not be as important to you.
The two cars also have different exterior styling. The X3 has a bolder, more modern design, while the X5 retains a more classic BMW look. If you want to project a more modern image, you may prefer the X3. If you like the classic BMW styling, you may like the X5 better.
Interior and Technology: Comfort and Innovation
When you slide into the driver’s seat of either the X3 or the X5, you’ll be greeted by a luxurious interior. Let’s take a closer look at the interior design and technology features to see how these two BMWs stack up.
Interior Design and Materials
Both models offer the kind of luxe aesthetic you’d expect from a BMW, but there are some subtle differences. The X3’s interior incorporates some newer lighting elements, giving it a slightly more modern feel. Pay attention to the material quality and overall feel of the cabin when you’re test driving both vehicles to see which one resonates with you more.
Technology and Features
Tech-wise, both the X3 and X5 are well-equipped. You’ll find a massive 14.9-inch screen in both models. However, the X3 is sporting BMW’s latest iDrive 9.0, a new Android-based system. The X5 uses iDrive 8.5.
Beyond the infotainment system, both vehicles offer premium audio systems and a suite of advanced safety features. Be sure to check out the standard and available features lists for each model to see which one best meets your needs. Do you want the parking assist feature, or are you okay with just a rearview camera? Does wireless charging matter to you?
Performance and Powertrains: Engine Options and Driving Experience
The BMW X3 and X5 offer different driving experiences, depending on what you’re looking for. Here’s a look at the engine options, how they perform, and what you can expect on the road.
Engine Specifications
If you’re after power, the X5 generally has more under the hood, although the X3 M50 closes the gap considerably. Here’s a look at two similar engine configurations:
- X5 40i: 3.0L Turbo I-6 w/ Mild Hybrid: 375 hp | 383 lb.ft | 0-60: 5.2 seconds
- X3 M50: 3.0L Turbo I-6 w/ Mild Hybrid: 393 hp | 428 lb.ft | 0-60: 4.4 seconds
The X5 also offers plug-in hybrid options, which can improve fuel economy and provide some all-electric driving range.
Driving Experience
The X3 is known for its agility and responsive handling, making it fun to drive on winding roads. The X5, on the other hand, is geared more toward comfort, especially on long drives. It absorbs bumps well and provides a smoother ride overall.
The X5 is also quieter inside. At 55 mph, the X5 registers around 51.6 dB, while the X3 is a bit louder at 53.9 dB.
Fuel Economy
If fuel economy is a priority, the X3 has a slight edge:
- X5: 23 city / 27 highway / 25 combined MPG
- X3: 25 city / 30 highway / 27 combined MPG
Practicality: Cargo Space, Towing Capacity, and Passenger Comfort
When it comes to SUVs, practicality is key. Let’s break down the X5 and X3 in terms of cargo space, towing, and passenger comfort to see which one comes out on top for everyday use and family needs.
Cargo Space
If you’re hauling groceries, sports equipment, or luggage, the X5 offers a bit more room to work with. With the second row up, you get 33.9 cubic feet of space, expanding to 72.3 cubic feet with all seats folded. The X3 isn’t far behind, offering 31.5 cubic feet with the seats in place and 67.1 cubic feet with them folded down. For most everyday tasks, the difference might not be huge, but if you regularly need to maximize cargo capacity, the X5 has the edge.
Towing Capacity
Need to tow a trailer, boat, or other equipment? The X5 is the clear winner here, boasting a towing capacity of 7,200 pounds. The X3, while still capable, maxes out at 4,850 pounds. If towing is a priority, the X5 is the better choice.
Passenger Comfort
In terms of passenger comfort, the X5 provides slightly more legroom (37.4 inches) and headroom (40.8 inches) compared to the X3 (36.3 inches and 38.2 inches, respectively). While the difference isn’t massive, it could be noticeable for taller passengers, especially on longer trips. Plus, the X5 offers an optional third row, making it a 7-seater, which is a significant advantage for larger families.
Pricing, Reliability, and Resale Value
Let’s talk dollars and cents. How do these two SUVs stack up when it comes to cost, dependability, and what you might get back when you sell them?
Pricing Comparison
Generally, you’ll find the X3 is a bit friendlier to your wallet, and that’s certainly reflected in the manufacturer’s suggested retail price. Here’s a quick comparison, as of the time I’m writing this:
- X3 M50 xDrive: MSRP $64,100 | Options: $5,550 | Destination: $1,175 | Total: $70,825
- X5 xDrive40i: MSRP $68,000 | Options: $6,715 | Destination: $1,175 | Total: $76,540
That’s a difference of $5,715. Of course, you’ll want to check with your local dealer for the most up-to-date pricing and any incentives that might be available.
Reliability and Resale Value
Don’t forget to factor in the cost of ownership. Both the X3 and X5 have generally good safety ratings, which is a plus. Resale values can fluctuate based on the model year, the condition of the vehicle, and the ever-changing demands of the market. Cars depreciate, so that’s also something to keep in mind.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is the BMW X3 so popular?
The BMW X3 hits a sweet spot for many drivers. It offers a good balance of practicality, luxury, and performance. It’s smaller and more maneuverable than the X5, making it easier to navigate city streets, but still provides ample cargo space and a comfortable ride for passengers. Plus, it carries the prestige of the BMW brand and offers a range of powerful engine options.
Which BMW is better, the X3 or the X5?
That really depends on your needs and priorities. The X5 is larger, more luxurious, and offers more powerful engine options, making it a great choice for families who need extra space and want a more premium driving experience. The X3 is more affordable, fuel-efficient, and easier to handle, making it a better fit for urban drivers or those who prioritize practicality and value.
What is the difference between X3 and X5 seats?
The X5 generally offers more spacious and luxurious seating compared to the X3. The X5 often comes standard with higher-quality materials, more adjustability options (like lumbar support and massage functions), and a generally more comfortable and supportive design, especially for longer journeys. While the X3’s seats are still comfortable, the X5 prioritizes a more premium seating experience due to its positioning as a larger, more upscale vehicle.
In Summary
The BMW X3 and X5 are both SUVs, but they cater to different needs. The X3 is more compact, fuel-efficient, and easier to maneuver in city traffic. It’s also the more budget-friendly choice and a great fit for smaller families.
The X5, on the other hand, is larger and more powerful. It offers more cargo space, better towing capacity, and a generally more luxurious experience. If you have a large family or need the extra utility, the X5 is likely the better option.
Ultimately, the best choice depends on your individual needs and preferences. I highly recommend test driving both models and carefully considering your priorities before making a decision. What’s most important to you: saving money, fuel efficiency, and city driving ease? Or space, power, and towing capacity? Your answer will point you to the right BMW SUV.