Hayward, Wisconsin, has a surprising number of restaurants for a small town. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a special night out, Hayward has something for everyone.
This guide highlights some of the best Hayward, Wisconsin restaurants, so you can be sure to find the perfect spot for your next meal.
Diverse dining experiences in Hayward
Hayward offers a range of dining experiences, from classic Northwoods cuisine to scenic waterfront restaurants.
Northwoods cuisine and supper clubs
Many Hayward restaurants specialize in Northwoods-style dining, featuring local ingredients and traditional dishes. Be sure to try a supper club, a Wisconsin tradition, for a relaxed atmosphere and classic comfort food.
One Hayward institution is the Tally Ho Supper Club, a family-owned restaurant serving steaks, seafood, pasta dishes, and nightly specials, along with special holiday meals.
Waterfront dining on the Chippewa Flowage
For a dining experience with a view, check out the waterfront restaurants on the Chippewa Flowage. Several full-service restaurants offer breakfast, lunch, and dinner with stunning waterfront settings.
Many of these restaurants are near popular spots for hiking, biking, fishing, and boating, so you can combine your meal with a day of outdoor fun.
Hayward restaurant options and specialties
When you’re ready to eat, Hayward has you covered with everything from Friday night fish fry to gourmet steak dinners. And if you’re lucky, you’ll find a restaurant that sources its ingredients from local farms and producers.
Whether you’re trying to feed a carload of hungry kids or you’d rather eat in your hotel room, you’ll find that many Hayward restaurants offer carryout and family-friendly menus.
And if you’re planning a special event, you might want to consider Tally Ho Supper Club, which accepts private parties and offers catering services. Many restaurants will also tailor menus to suit your needs.
In addition to serving up delicious food, some Hayward restaurants actively support the local community through fundraising and other efforts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who owns The Social in Hayward, WI?
The Social, a popular spot known for its relaxed atmosphere, great food, and friendly service, is owned and operated by Chris and his wife, Sarah. They’ve poured their heart into creating a welcoming space for locals and visitors alike.
What’s the #1 restaurant in the US?
Ah, the million-dollar question! The “best” restaurant is subjective and changes all the time based on trends and reviews. There’s no single, universally agreed-upon #1 restaurant in the US, but sites like Yelp, Michelin Guide, and James Beard Foundation often highlight top contenders.
What is a fun fact about Hayward, Wisconsin?
Here’s a fun one: Hayward is home to the world’s largest musky! This giant fiberglass fish, affectionately known as “The Big Muskie,” stands tall at the Freshwater Fishing Hall of Fame and Museum, drawing visitors from all over. It’s a must-see photo op!
Is there a flea market in Hayward, Wisconsin on Mondays?
While Hayward has a vibrant market scene, specific flea market schedules can vary. I recommend checking local listings, community bulletin boards, or contacting the Hayward Area Chamber of Commerce to confirm if a flea market operates on Mondays during your visit. Sometimes they are only seasonal or weekends only.
The Bottom Line
From cozy cafes to family-friendly restaurants to supper clubs with Northwoods charm, Hayward, Wisconsin, has a dining experience for every taste and occasion.
So, next time you’re in the Hayward area, be sure to explore the local restaurants and savor all the flavors of this special part of Wisconsin.