Santa Rosa’s food scene is bustling, and Italian cuisine is no exception! From classic, old-school red sauce joints to modern takes on regional Italian cooking, you’re sure to find something to love.
Sonoma County is no stranger to great Italian food either. In the 1800s, scores of Italian immigrants flocked to the area, bringing their treasured family recipes and cooking traditions with them.
Ready to dig in? Here’s a list of the best Italian Santa Rosa restaurants to help you discover your next favorite meal.
Dining Editor’s Top Italian Restaurant Picks in Santa Rosa
When I’m looking for the best Italian restaurants, I’m not just thinking about the food. I’m thinking about the whole experience. Is the food fresh and well-prepared? Does the restaurant have a great vibe? Is the service impeccable? And, most importantly, do I leave feeling like I’ve had a memorable meal?
Santa Rosa has a great variety of Italian restaurants, from old-school red-sauce joints to modern spots that put a contemporary spin on classic dishes. Here are a few of my favorites right now:
- Campanella: This place is known for its handmade pasta and cozy atmosphere. Don’t miss the tagliatelle with wild boar ragu.
- Portico: If you’re looking for a more upscale experience, Portico is the place to go. The wine list is extensive, and the seafood dishes are always top-notch.
- L’Oro Di Napoli: For authentic Neapolitan pizza, this is the real deal. The crust is perfectly charred, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful.
- Cafe Citti: A Santa Rosa institution, Cafe Citti is the perfect spot for a casual lunch or dinner. The sandwiches are legendary, and the salads are always a good choice.
- Grata Italian Eatery: This newer spot is quickly gaining a following for its creative pasta dishes and friendly service. Try the cacio e pepe – it’s divine.
Reader’s favorite Italian restaurants in Santa Rosa
When you’re looking for the best local food, sometimes it’s best to go straight to the source: the people who live, work, and eat in the area. So, we asked around, collected feedback, and compiled a list of some of the most beloved Italian restaurants in Santa Rosa.
Riviera Ristorante
This family-run restaurant has earned a reputation for its authentic and diverse menu. As Jed Spencer said on Facebook, “Riviera is my favorite. Authentic, diverse and delicious menu. The lamb ravioli is outstanding.”
Baci Cafe & Wine Bar
Baci is another favorite, known for its great vibe, welcoming owners and staff, and an impressive wine list. Paula Radell raves, “Love the food, the vibe, the owners and staff, and the wine list.”
Cibo Rustico
If you’re looking for a place where you’ll feel like family, Cibo Rustico is a must-try. One reader mentioned, “Cibos, owner treats you amazingly and might even pour you a little complimentary glass of his favorite wine.”
LoCoco’s Cucina Rustica
LoCoco’s is known around town for its generous portions of traditional Italian-American dishes. You’ll find everything from lasagna and spaghetti to chicken parmesan and eggplant rollatini on the menu.
Exploring Other Highly-Rated Italian Restaurants in Santa Rosa
Santa Rosa is a hotbed of Italian culinary talent, so while the restaurants above have earned the highest honors, there are several other Italian restaurants that are well worth a visit.
Honorable Mentions: Expanding Your Options
Don’t let a restaurant’s absence from “best of” lists dissuade you. These restaurants are all excellent places to enjoy Italian cuisine.
Featured Restaurants
- Sugo Trattoria: This restaurant features a cozy ambiance and a menu packed with authentic Italian dishes.
- Trattoria Roma: Trattoria Roma is known for its warm, inviting atmosphere and traditional Roman cuisine.
- Alfredo’s Italian Restaurant: A long-time Santa Rosa favorite, Alfredo’s is loved for its classic Italian-American fare and friendly service.
- Pizzando: If you’re looking for pizza, Pizzando offers a wide range of delicious, wood-fired pies with creative topping combinations.
How to choose the right Italian restaurant in Santa Rosa
Santa Rosa has a ton of great Italian restaurants. Here are a few things to think about when you’re trying to decide where to go:
- Price: Some restaurants are fancy and pricey, while others are more casual and affordable.
- Dietary needs: Many places offer gluten-free pasta, vegetarian options, and other accommodations.
- Atmosphere: Are you looking for a romantic date night spot? A place to bring the whole family? Or a lively spot with outdoor seating?
- Cuisine: Do you want traditional Italian dishes? Something with a California twist? Or a taste of a specific region of Italy?
Thinking about these factors can help you narrow down your choices and find the perfect spot.
The Bottom Line
Whether you’re craving classic red-sauce Italian-American comfort food or something more modern and creative, Santa Rosa offers a wide range of Italian restaurants that are sure to please.
The best way to find your favorite is to get out there and explore all the options. Try the pizza at one place, the pasta at another, and the dessert at a third. And don’t forget to check out the smaller, family-run restaurants that add so much character to Santa Rosa’s dining scene.
By supporting these local businesses, you’re not just enjoying a delicious meal; you’re also helping to keep Santa Rosa vibrant and unique.