Boothbay Restaurants Maine: Where to Eat Like a Local

Boothbay Harbor: A Food Lover’s Paradise

Boothbay Harbor isn’t just a pretty face; it’s a culinary destination. Known for its fresh-off-the-boat seafood, undeniable charm, and diverse options for dining, the area has something for every palate. You can find everything from casual lobster shacks where you can crack open a lobster with a view to upscale restaurants serving gourmet meals.

This guide is your passport to the best restaurants, cafes, and food experiences Boothbay has to offer. We’re here to help both visitors and locals alike discover hidden gems and make delicious choices.

So, what can you expect to find inside? We’ll explore a wide range of dining options, from seafood joints and laid-back eateries to fancy restaurants that will wow you.

We’ll also fill you in on the local specialties you won’t want to miss, like lobster rolls dripping with butter, classic clambakes, and blueberry desserts that taste like summer. Plus, we’ll share tips on how to make reservations, where to find the perfect picnic spot, and how to explore other nearby towns with great food.

Seafood Sensations: Must-Try Seafood Restaurants

It’s no secret that Maine is synonymous with seafood, and Boothbay Harbor is no exception. Here’s a peek at some of the seafood experiences you won’t want to miss.

Classic Lobster Shacks and Waterfront Dining

Let’s face it: enjoying Maine lobster is a quintessential New England experience. In Boothbay Harbor, you’ll find lobster prepared just about any way you can imagine: steamed, boiled, in a lobster roll, or as the centerpiece of a traditional clambake.

For a truly authentic experience, seek out the classic lobster shacks. Robinson’s Wharf is a local favorite, known for its incredibly fresh seafood and stunning waterfront views. Look for spots with outdoor seating so you can soak in the harbor views while you crack into a lobster.

Upscale Seafood Restaurants

If you’re in the mood for something a bit more refined, Boothbay Harbor also offers a selection of upscale seafood restaurants that focus on serving the freshest catch prepared with innovative culinary techniques. These establishments often emphasize locally sourced ingredients, ensuring a true taste of Maine.

Harborside 1901, which replaced the old Harborside Tavern, now offers sushi and other upscale seafood dishes. Be on the lookout for restaurants that feature an extensive wine list and a romantic ambiance, perfect for a special occasion.

Casual Dining and Local Favorites

Boothbay and Boothbay Harbor offer a wide range of dining experiences, from the elegant and upscale to the casual and budget-friendly. If you’re looking for something easygoing and affordable, here are a few local favorites to consider.

Cafes and Casual Eateries

Boothbay Harbor has many cafes and casual eateries where you can relax and enjoy some delicious, affordable food. Here are a couple of places where you might want to grab a quick bite:

• Mama D’s Cafe: This is a local favorite for breakfast and lunch.
• Kelly’s Cafe: A relative newcomer to the area.

Pubs and Taverns

If you’re looking for hearty food and local brews, you may want to check out one of the area’s pubs or taverns.

• Watershed Tavern: Known for its classic pub fare and lively atmosphere.
• Thistle Inn: A historic inn with both a restaurant and a pub.

Whether you’re in the mood for a quick breakfast, a leisurely lunch, or a hearty dinner, Boothbay Harbor has plenty of casual dining options to satisfy your cravings. Be sure to check out these local favorites for a taste of Maine’s culinary charm.

A Taste of Italy and Beyond: Exploring Diverse Cuisines

While seafood is a staple, Boothbay Harbor restaurants offer a range of flavors to satisfy any craving. Here’s a peek at some of the other culinary adventures you can embark on.

Italian Restaurants in Boothbay Harbor

Craving pasta? Boothbay has you covered. For authentic Italian flavors, Ports of Italy is a local favorite. Look for restaurants that pride themselves on fresh, homemade pasta and traditional dishes passed down through generations.

Exploring Other Culinary Options

Not in the mood for seafood or Italian? No problem!

BBQ and More

If you’re a fan of BBQ, check out the Bridge House BBQ, a newer addition to the Boothbay Harbor dining scene.

Variety is the Spice of Life

Boothbay Harbor also boasts a variety of restaurants offering everything from classic American comfort food to exciting international flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for a juicy burger, spicy tacos, or flavorful stir-fry, you’re sure to find something to tantalize your taste buds.

Sweet Treats and Coffee Breaks

Sometimes, you just want something sweet or a cup of coffee to perk you up, and Boothbay has you covered.

Ice Cream and Fudge Shops

Boothbay Harbor has plenty of options for indulging your sweet tooth, including homemade ice cream, creamy fudge, and candies of all kinds.

Harbor Treats is one of the newer shops, taking the place of the beloved Wannawaf at 7A Wharf St. They serve Gifford’s Ice Cream, which is made in Maine.

Coffee Shops and Bakeries

If you’re looking for a place to start your day, one of the local coffee shops might be just what you need. Most offer a wide variety of coffee drinks, along with pastries and light breakfast fare. Grab a cup and a pastry, and you’ll be ready to explore all that Boothbay has to offer!

The Clambake Experience

If you’re visiting coastal Maine, you can’t leave without experiencing an authentic New England clambake.

What is a clambake?

A clambake is a traditional New England feast in which lobster, clams, corn on the cob, and potatoes are cooked over seaweed and hot rocks. These feasts have historical roots in Native American cooking methods and have evolved into a celebratory meal often enjoyed outdoors.

Where to enjoy a clambake

One of the best-known spots for a traditional clambake is Cabbage Island Clambakes, a popular destination that requires advance reservations.

Tips for a memorable clambake

When you head out for your clambake, keep these tips in mind:

• Dress casually and comfortably.
• Bring a light jacket or sweater, as evenings by the water can be cool.
• Be prepared to get a little messy as you crack open lobsters and clams.
• Most importantly, come hungry and ready to savor the flavors of the sea!

Picnic perfect: Parks, beaches, and provisions

Boothbay Harbor and its surrounding areas are gorgeous, and sometimes the best restaurant is the one you create yourself! Here’s how to have a picnic to remember.

Finding the perfect picnic spot

Boothbay Harbor is awash in scenic parks, beaches, and overlooks that are perfect for a romantic lunch or a family feast. Here are a few ideas:

• Barter’s Island. Just a short drive from Boothbay, Barter’s Island offers some stunning views and peaceful spots to unfurl a blanket.
• Hendricks Head Beach. Who doesn’t love dining with their toes in the sand?
• Ocean Point. The views from Ocean Point are breathtaking.

Stocking up on picnic supplies

You’ll find everything you need for the perfect picnic at these local markets:

• Hannaford’s. This full-service grocery store is open seven days a week.
• Woodsong Market. A newer addition to the area, Woodsong Market specializes in local and organic foods.

Also, be sure to check out the local farmers’ markets for fresh produce and unique Maine-made goodies.

Beyond Boothbay: Exploring Nearby Culinary Gems

If you’re up for a short drive, you can find even more great food near Boothbay.

Damariscotta

Damariscotta is known as the oyster capital of Maine, so if you’re a fan of those briny bivalves, you’ll want to check out some of Damariscotta’s restaurants that specialize in oysters and other fresh seafood.

Wiscasset

Just a few miles away, Wiscasset is home to Red’s Eats, a tiny lobster shack that’s famous for its lobster rolls and lines that can stretch down the block.

Portland

About an hour to the south, Portland has a diverse and vibrant culinary scene that’s worth exploring. From fresh seafood to innovative farm-to-table cuisine, Portland has something for everyone. Try Eventide Oyster Co. for brown butter lobster rolls or Fore Street for wood-grilled entrees.

Frequently Asked Questions

Closing Thoughts

Boothbay Harbor is truly a culinary gem on the Maine coast. From the freshest seafood pulled straight from the Atlantic to diverse dining options that cater to every taste, the area offers a dining experience as memorable as its charming, picturesque atmosphere.

Whether you’re craving a classic lobster roll, a plate of perfectly fried clams, or an innovative dish featuring locally sourced ingredients, Boothbay Harbor’s many restaurants, cafes, and food experiences are waiting to be discovered. Don’t be afraid to venture off the beaten path – some of the best meals are found in the most unexpected places.

Before you go, a few final tips: Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak season. Be sure to check restaurant websites for the most up-to-date hours and menus. And most importantly, remember that by choosing to dine in Boothbay Harbor, you’re supporting local businesses and contributing to the vibrant community that makes this area so special.