There’s something special about a Wisconsin supper club. It’s more than just a restaurant; it’s an experience. Think dimly lit dining rooms, a friendly atmosphere, and a hefty dose of nostalgia.
Supper clubs are a deeply rooted part of Wisconsin’s culinary history, and they’ve managed to maintain their charm and appeal through the years. Whether you’re a local looking for a comforting meal or a tourist eager to experience a true Wisconsin tradition, the supper clubs around Madison, WI, offer something for everyone.
From classic spots serving up traditional Friday fish fry to more modern takes on the supper club experience, we’re going to explore some of the best supper clubs Madison, WI, has to offer. Get ready for good food, good drinks, and good times!
What is the Wisconsin supper club experience?
Wisconsin supper clubs are more than just restaurants; they’re a whole vibe. Think cozy, nostalgic, and always welcoming. The goal is to relax and enjoy a sociable evening out.
Here are a few things that define a Wisconsin supper club:
- Classic menu. Friday fish fry is practically mandatory, along with prime rib, and those iconic relish trays. And you absolutely have to order an Old Fashioned.
- Hospitality. Supper clubs are known for their friendly service and personal touches.
The supper club as a social hub
Supper clubs are community gathering places, playing a big role in local culture and traditions. Many offer special events like happy hour, Sunday brunch, or live music, too.
Madison’s Iconic Supper Clubs: A Detailed Look
Madison and its surrounding areas are home to some truly remarkable supper clubs. Here’s a peek at a few of the most beloved:
- Harvey House. For a fine dining experience, check out the Harvey House, where you can dine in a renovated train car. The ambiance is special, and the menu is upscale.
- The Del-Bar. The Del-Bar is a Frank Lloyd Wright-inspired supper club with high-quality food and a Mad Men vibe. The architecture is stunning, and the atmosphere is sophisticated.
- Hob Knob Supper Club. You’ll find scenic lake views and a cool 1950s vibe at the Hob Nob.
- Toby’s Supper Club. Toby’s is known for its free homemade cinnamon rolls (weekdays only). It’s a family-friendly place.
- Maple Tree Supper Club. This supper club has a soup and salad bar and a Wednesday night buffet, along with all the traditional supper club fare.
- Jones’ Black Angus. The soup and salad bar here is extensive, and there’s a wide selection of Wisconsin cheeses.
- Wissota High Shores Supper Club. You’ll enjoy the lake view and the soup and salad bar, especially the clam chowder.
- Ishnala Supper Club. Ishnala is known for its picturesque setting and classic supper club menu.
- House of Embers Restaurant. This spot has a cozy atmosphere and serves traditional dishes.
- Club 23. For a modern take on the supper club experience, check out Club 23.
- Rupp’s Supper Club. Rupp’s is a local favorite known for its friendly service.
- Buckatabon Tavern & Supper Club. Here, you’ll find a combo of tavern atmosphere and supper club traditions.
- Dorf Haus Supper Club. Experience German cuisine at this supper club.
- Red Circle Inn. As Wisconsin’s oldest restaurant, the Red Circle Inn provides a historic supper club experience.
- Black Otter Supper Club. This supper club emphasizes classic dishes in a rustic setting.
- Wallace Lake Supper Club. This supper club is known for its lakeside setting and traditional menu.
Menu highlights and signature dishes
You’ll find some overlap in the menus at Wisconsin supper clubs. Many offer Friday fish fry, prime rib, and steaks. Wisconsin cheese curds are usually on the menu, along with other regional specialties. Some supper clubs have their own signature dishes, such as Superior whitefish.
Beyond the Food: Ambiance, Entertainment, and Special Events
While the food at a Wisconsin supper club is definitely a draw, the overall experience is about so much more than what’s on the plate. It’s about the atmosphere, the history, and the unique entertainment that makes each club special.
The Importance of Ambiance
Step inside a supper club, and you’re stepping back in time. The decor, the lighting, and the music all play a role in creating an immersive experience. Some clubs, like The Del-Bar in Wisconsin Dells, evoke a “Mad Men” vibe with their mid-century modern design and dimly lit dining rooms. Others are housed in historic buildings, adding another layer of charm and character.
Entertainment and Special Events
Many supper clubs offer live music, themed nights, and other entertainment to keep things lively. The Dorf Haus, for example, is known for its regular polka nights. You can also find special events like happy hour (Tuesday-Saturday 4-6pm), fish fry (Tuesday & Friday), and Sunday brunch (9am-2pm) at some establishments. Be on the lookout for drink promotions, like $8 Old Fashioneds on Friday & Saturday, or even a build-your-own Bloody Mary bar during Sunday brunch for a truly Wisconsin experience!
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the deal with supper clubs in Wisconsin?
Okay, so picture this: It’s a Friday night, you’re a little ways outside of town, and you pull up to a cozy, maybe even slightly retro-looking spot. That’s probably a Wisconsin supper club. They’re not fancy, but they are an institution. Think classic cocktails (Old Fashioneds, anyone?), hearty comfort food like prime rib and Friday fish fry, and a super friendly, welcoming atmosphere. It’s less about the Michelin stars and more about good times and good company. They’re a throwback to a simpler era, and we Wisconsinites love them.
What happens at a supper club?
The experience usually starts at the bar, where you grab a drink (again, Old Fashioned is practically mandatory) and maybe some appetizers. You put your name in for a table – because most of the popular spots fill up fast. Then, when you’re seated, you’re in for a feast. Entrees often come with relish trays, salads, soup, and sides galore. Portions are generous, and the focus is on satisfying, home-style cooking. It’s a social experience, a culinary experience, and a Wisconsin experience all rolled into one. And don’t forget dessert – grasshopper pie is a must-try!
To Conclude
Wisconsin supper clubs offer more than just a meal; they offer an experience. They’re a unique blend of good food, old-fashioned charm, and a sense of community that’s hard to find anywhere else. It’s a taste of Wisconsin history, served with a smile and an Old Fashioned.
If you’re in the Madison area, I encourage you to explore the diverse supper club scene. Each one has its own personality and specialties, but you’re likely to find good food, friendly service, and a memorable atmosphere no matter where you go.
Supper clubs are a treasured part of Wisconsin culture, and it’s important to support and preserve these unique culinary traditions for generations to come. So, gather your friends and family, make a reservation, and experience the magic of a Wisconsin supper club for yourself!