A Food Lover’s Tour of Historic St. Augustine
St. Augustine is having a culinary moment. It’s been named “The South’s Best Food Town” and the “#1 Small Town in the South.” But it’s not just hype; the food scene here is genuinely exciting and constantly evolving.
What makes the restaurants in historic St. Augustine so special? It’s the blend of old-world charm and modern culinary creativity. You’ll find a strong emphasis on fresh, local ingredients, creating an authentic farm-to-table experience in many places.
This guide will take you through some of the most interesting restaurants St. Augustine has to offer. We’ll explore their unique stories, their history, and the delicious food they serve. From long-standing institutions to the newest spots on the block, we’ll cover a range of options for both visitors and locals looking for a memorable meal.
Historic Restaurants: A Taste of St. Augustine’s Past
One of the great things about St. Augustine is that the past is always present. You can feel it in the coquina walls, see it in the architecture, and even taste it in the food! Here are a couple of historic restaurants that offer a delicious glimpse into St. Augustine’s past.
Columbia Restaurant: A Century of Tradition
History and Legacy
The Columbia Restaurant is a St. Augustine landmark, serving up traditional Spanish cuisine since 1905. That’s more than a century of delicious food and happy customers!
Cuisine and Atmosphere
If you’re looking for authentic Spanish food in a beautiful, historic setting, the Columbia Restaurant is a must-try. The menu reflects St. Augustine’s Spanish heritage, and the atmosphere is both elegant and inviting.
The Raintree Restaurant: Victorian Elegance
Ambiance and Setting
Housed in a beautifully restored Victorian home, The Raintree Restaurant offers a dining experience unlike any other. The building itself is a piece of history, and the elegant ambiance perfectly complements the historic charm of St. Augustine.
Menu Highlights
The Raintree’s menu is diverse and internationally influenced, with something to please every palate. It’s known for its fine dining experience and attentive service, making it a perfect spot for a special occasion or a memorable night out.
Seafood Sensations: Coastal Cuisine at its Finest
When you’re visiting a historic coastal town like St. Augustine, you simply must sample the local seafood. Here are a few places you can’t miss:
Catch 27: Local Seafood, Local Flavor
Catch 27 focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, with a heavy emphasis on seafood. The restaurant prides itself on supporting local fishermen and farmers, bringing the freshest possible flavors to your table.
Menu highlights include their famous Deviled Eggs with Fried Oysters and the Minorcan Seafood Chowder, a St. Augustine staple. You’ll find a variety of other seafood dishes too, all designed to showcase the best of the coast.
St. Augustine Fish Camp: A Modern Take on Seafood
St. Augustine Fish Camp is a newer restaurant from the team behind local favorites Marker 32 and Palm Valley Fish Camp, bringing a fresh perspective to seafood dining in the area. You’ll find it across the Bridge of Lions in the newly revitalized historic Ice Plant.
The restaurant provides a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for enjoying fresh seafood with friends and family. The menu includes classic seafood dishes alongside innovative creations, so there’s something for everyone.
DJ’s Clam Shack: Casual Coastal Eats
If you’re looking for a truly laid-back experience, head to DJ’s Clam Shack. This spot offers a casual, no-frills dining experience, reminiscent of a classic seafood shack. They’re known for their fresh seafood and affordable prices, making it a great option for a quick and tasty bite.
Menu favorites include their crispy clam strips, perfectly fried shrimp, and satisfying fish sandwiches. It’s the perfect place to grab a casual lunch or dinner after a day of exploring the city.
Diverse Culinary Experiences: Exploring Global Flavors
While St. Augustine has its share of seafood shacks and oyster bars, you can also find restaurants that offer a taste of flavors from around the world.
The Floridian: Southern Comfort with a Twist
If you’re in the mood for something uniquely Southern, try The Floridian, which puts a modern spin on Southern cuisine, using ingredients sourced from local farms and fisheries. The restaurant is known for its creative dishes and commitment to sustainability. You’ll find dishes that celebrate the flavors of the South, like fried green tomatoes, shrimp and grits, and chicken and dumplings.
Meehan’s Irish Pub & Seafood House: A Taste of Ireland
For an authentic Irish pub experience, head to Meehan’s, where you can enjoy traditional music and decor. The menu is diverse, with both Irish and seafood options. With different dining areas designed to suit different preferences, Meehan’s is a great place to enjoy a pint of Guinness and classic Irish dishes like shepherd’s pie, fish and chips, and bangers and mash.
Nonna’s Trattoria: Authentic Italian Cuisine
Nonna’s Trattoria offers authentic Italian cuisine, made from family recipes passed down through generations. The restaurant captures the essence of Italian home cooking in a warm and inviting atmosphere that’s perfect for a family meal. You’ll find pasta dishes, wood-fired pizzas, and classic Italian desserts like tiramisu and cannoli. It’s a little taste of the old country in the nation’s oldest city.
Modern Gastronomy: Innovative and Trendy Eateries
While St. Augustine celebrates its history, it also embraces modern culinary trends. Here are a few restaurants that offer innovative dining experiences.
Forgotten Tonic: Craft Cocktails and Cajun Flavors
If you’re looking for a sophisticated cocktail in a lively atmosphere, check out Forgotten Tonic. They’re known for their craft cocktails and unique flavor combinations, and their menu is influenced by Cajun cuisine.
You can get your fill of Cajun egg rolls, blackened redfish, and a variety of other appetizers, entrees, and desserts.
The Ice Plant: A Historical Cocktail Experience
The Ice Plant offers a cool cocktail experience in a renovated ice plant. The setting combines industrial elements with a touch of elegance.
The bar features craft cocktails made with local ingredients and house-made syrups. It’s a memorable spot to enjoy a thoughtfully prepared cocktail.
Treylor Park: Southern Comfort Food with a Twist
For a fun and quirky dining experience, try Treylor Park, which offers Southern comfort food with creative twists.
You’ll find unique dish combinations and playful plating here. It’s a great spot if you’re looking for something a little different.
In Closing
St. Augustine offers a diverse culinary landscape, with something to please every palate. Whether you’re looking for historic restaurants that whisper tales of centuries past or modern gastropubs pushing the boundaries of flavor, you’ll find it here. The city’s dining scene is constantly evolving, offering new experiences alongside beloved classics.
I encourage both visitors and locals to explore the many restaurants that St. Augustine has to offer. Venture off the beaten path and discover hidden gems, savor the unique flavors that define this historic city, and create lasting memories with every bite.
St. Augustine’s food scene is more than just a collection of restaurants; it’s a reflection of the city’s rich history, vibrant culture, and enduring spirit. These eateries are an integral part of the St. Augustine experience, offering a taste of the past and a glimpse into the future of this captivating city.