Bar Harbor, Maine, is a popular tourist destination and the gateway to Acadia National Park. But it’s also heaven for anyone who loves seafood and delicious food in general!
This guide explores some of the best restaurants Bar Harbor has to offer, from long-standing local favorites to newer culinary ventures. We’ll focus on the freshest seafood, of course, but also highlight some unique dining experiences that go beyond the lobster pound.
We hope this helps you plan an unforgettable gastronomic journey in Bar Harbor!
Geddy’s: A Bar Harbor Icon
If you’re looking for a restaurant that’s been around the block, Geddy’s is it. This waterfront restaurant has been a Bar Harbor fixture for over 50 years.
History and Ambiance
Geddy’s is known for its lively vibe, historical decor, and the occasional performance by a well-known musician. Its long history makes it a Bar Harbor tradition.
Menu Highlights
If you’re in Maine, you know you need to try the lobster. Geddy’s specializes in fresh Maine lobster and sustainable seafood. You can even pick your own lobster from the live tank!
The menu is varied, with options like lobster rolls, lobster bake, wood-fired pizza, and burgers. If you’re vegetarian or vegan, you’ll find something to enjoy here, too. Plus, 98% of the menu is gluten-free.
Unique Features
Geddy’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience. You can browse the unique shops, “Geddy’s Down-Under” and “Geddy’s By The Sea,” for gifts, clothing, and jewelry.
The restaurant has won a TripAdvisor 2024 “Certificate of Excellence” Award and was named “Business of the Year” by the Bar Harbor Chamber of Commerce.
McKay’s Public House: Elevated Pub Fare
McKay’s Public House is a local favorite that celebrated its 20th anniversary in 2023. They’re known for having excellent versions of familiar pub foods, with an emphasis on fresh seafood and local ingredients. That might sound like a lot of places in Bar Harbor, but McKay’s is a cut above.
Two favorites are the bruleed oysters, which some people say are even better than Oysters Rockefeller, and the seafood risotto. The starters on the menu are especially good, so come hungry!
The popularity and longevity of McKay’s shows their commitment to high-quality food and local sourcing in a small town with a lot of competition.
West Street Cafe: Classic Maine Cuisine
Many reviewers say that if you want a real taste of Maine, you should head to West Street Cafe. This restaurant has a reputation for its classic regional dishes.
Their lobster rolls are a must-try. If you order the “Downeast Special,” you’ll get a lobster roll made with a whopping 1.25 pounds of lobster meat.
Be sure to save room for dessert so you can sample their blueberry pie. Maine is a major blueberry producer. In 2021, the state produced almost 105 million pounds of blueberries!
Galyn’s Restaurant: History and Tradition
Galyn’s has been serving Bar Harbor since 1986, and a meal there feels like stepping back in time. They pride themselves on a traditional dining experience.
The menu is full of classic seafood dishes, like lobster bisque. People rave about their “lazy lobster,” which is a must-try.
If you’re looking for a restaurant with history and a commitment to classic Maine fare, Galyn’s is a great choice.
Beyond the mainstream: Other culinary gems
While some Bar Harbor restaurants are famous for their lobster rolls, others are known for the sweet treats they offer. Here are a few less well-known spots you might want to check out.
Ben & Bill’s Chocolate Emporium: A sweet adventure
Ben & Bill’s is home to 64 flavors of ice cream and a dozen different gelatos, including a unique flavor: lobster. While some people find the texture and taste of the lobster ice cream a little off-putting, it’s worth trying just for the novelty.
Sand Bar Cottage Inn: A pleasant breakfast
If you’re looking for a pleasant breakfast spot, the Sand Bar Cottage Inn offers a menu that includes Nantucket pie and pumpkin pancakes.
Recommendations for future exploration
Here are a few other Bar Harbor restaurants you might want to explore:
- The Reading Room, for fine dining with ocean views
- Paddy’s, for lively Irish pub fare
- Havana, for a taste of Cuban cuisine
Making the Most of Your Bar Harbor Restaurant Experience
Bar Harbor is a foodie paradise, so you’ll want to plan your culinary adventures carefully. Here are a few tips:
- Look for fresh, local ingredients. Bar Harbor is known for its seafood, so prioritize restaurants that source their ingredients locally.
- Study menus ahead of time. Most restaurants post their menus online. Take a look and decide what you want to try.
- Consider a local guide. Knowledgeable local guides can provide history, context, and recommendations for hidden gems.
- Don’t be afraid to try new things! Lobster rolls and blueberry pie are Bar Harbor staples, but there are plenty of other local dishes to explore.
Conclusion
Whether you want a taste of history at a classic seafood house or prefer to try some creative pub fare, Bar Harbor has something for everyone’s palate. With so many great options, the only problem you’ll have is deciding where to go!
When you’re in Bar Harbor, be sure to try some local favorites, and don’t miss any opportunity to sample the fresh ingredients the region is known for.
So, go ahead: Embark on a culinary adventure and savor the unique and delicious flavors of Bar Harbor. You’re sure to make some lasting memories!